Her family made different school choices than we did. We still want the same things.
Ultimately, I think Hannah-Jones’ family and ours asked different questions a decade ago. We came to different conclusions. We had different outcomes, to a point. But I like to think we want the same things. The best possible education for our kids and for our communities.
Nikole Hannah-Jones is a lightning rod. Her essay on her daughter’s experience in the New York City's public school system is no exception.
I read her essay, several think pieces based on her essay, and listened to a few podcasts about it, including her appearance on This American Life with her daughter. Her core question is similar to what we asked ourselves a decade ago when it was time to evaluate kindergartens for The Kid.
Ultimately, I think Esau McCaulley captured the essence of what I feel best on his podcast when he said, "I'm trying to think for my Black child, 'what can I do that's going to help this child have a positive understanding of Jesus and God and His word and their own identity as someone who's made in the image of God as a Black or Brown girl or boy and get a high quality education.''"
Why do McCaulley's words resonate with me? We are a transracial family. We all experience race differently, and my fervent hope is that she faces less overt discrimination in a predominantly Black school so she can focus on learning.
Finding these experiences in Detroit can be difficult. We are fortunate enough to be in a neighborhood surrounded by schools and have the means to transport The Kid to school. According to Detroit Partnership for Education Equity & Research at Wayne State University’s School of Education, we are outliers.
The group also correctly identifies that the school choice landscape in Detroit is difficult to navigate, with little transparency or regulation. While the research I linked to is from 2023, I can tell you from our experience that the situation was the same if not a little worse a few years earlier. There is no singular source of truth for data on school performance, which gives schools with great reputations an advantage, even when they underperform.
It is important to note that according to The Educational Opportunity Project at Stanford University that for the last few years, the Detroit Public Schools Community District has improved outcomes for students faster than most districts in the state, regardless of race, family income, or gender. Certainly, some of this is because the floor was so low, but the district has made strides since the debacle of emergency management for what is now DPSCD began in 1999.
We ended up settling on a charter school a 15-minute drive from home for The Kid. Detroit Achievement Academy came highly recommended from the founder of the preschool we loved.
When we walked into DAA for our first visit, we were sold. We saw diversity in the instructional and support staff. We appreciated its approach to learning and community, including the neighborhood immediately surrounding the school. We were proud when this past June, The Kid graduated from eighth grade there, honored as one of the “Forever Flames” who attended the school from kindergarten.
In their most recent annual report, DAA notes that it exceeded regional averages in every grade for every content area in the 2025-2026 school year. I like to think the roots of that success run through what we saw on that first visit.
There are always rough spots in a nine-year relationship, but we appreciated the ability to communicate freely with teachers and that teacher turnover seemed quite low from year to year. There were also plenty of opportunities for us to participate as volunteers or participate in celebrations of learning, building that sense of community that is what I appreciated most about DAA.
Ultimately, I think Hannah-Jones’ family and ours asked different questions a decade ago. We came to different conclusions. We had different outcomes, to a point. We both have young Black women enrolled in the preeminent high school in our city.
But I like to think we want the same things. The best possible education for our kids and for our communities. We can only get there by asking difficult questions, holding school leaders accountable, giving teachers the resources they need, and supporting students' families so the kids can focus on learning.
I hope we get there soon.